Papers and proposals are two types of documents that are often used in the academic and professional world, but they have different purposes and characteristics. The following are the differences between a paper and a proposal:
-
Main Purpose:
- Paper: The main purpose of a paper is to present information, arguments, analysis, or research results on certain topics to readers. Papers are used to communicate the knowledge or understanding that the author has obtained to the reader.
- Proposal: A proposal has the main objective of proposing an idea or plan to stakeholders or authorized parties. Proposals are usually used to request approval, support, or resources for a project or initiative.
-
Contents:
- Paper: Papers usually contain analysis, arguments, literature reviews, research findings, and in-depth conclusions about a topic. It must be supported by strong evidence and references.
- Proposal: A proposal contains details about what will be done in a project or initiative, including goals, methods, resources required, schedule, and expected benefits.
-
Structure:
- Papers: Papers usually have a typical structure, such as introduction, background, literature review, research methods , results, discussion, and conclusions. This depends on the type of paper and the guidelines provided.
- Proposal: Proposals also have a general structure, including an executive summary, background, problem, objectives, methods, budget, schedule, and list of references.
-
Writing Style:
- Papers: Papers should be written in formal and academic language, and arranged in a logical and structured manner. Usually addressed to an audience that is knowledgeable about the topic.
- Proposals: Proposals can be written in more structured and technical language than a typical paper. It should be easy to understand for readers who may not have in-depth knowledge of the topic.
-
Reader Objective:
- Paper: Reader papers are usually fellow academics or professionals who are interested in the topic at hand and want to understand more deeply about the subject.
- Proposals: Readers of proposals are the authorities who must decide whether to support or reject a project or initiative. The proposal must convince the reader to provide the requested consent or resources.
It is important to understand the difference between a paper and a proposal in order to craft a document that suits its purpose and audience . Both have an important role in various contexts, both in the academic and professional world.
To understand more about the differences between papers and proposals. Then you can read a more detailed explanation regarding the differences between papers and proposals below.
What is a paper and what is a proposal?
Papers and proposals are two different types of documents with their respective purposes and characteristics. Here are the basic definitions of both:
-
Paper:
- Paper is a written document which is used to present information, analysis, arguments, or research results on a particular topic.
- The main purpose of a paper is to communicate the author’s knowledge, findings, or understanding to readers.
- Paper usually written in formal and academic language, and contains arguments supported by strong evidence and references.
- Papers are often used in the academic world to document research, analysis, or understanding of a topic and can be published in journals scientific or presented at a conference.
-
Proposal:
- Proposal is a document used to propose ideas, plans, or projects to authorized parties or stakeholders with the aim of requesting approval, support, or resources to implement the idea or plan.
- The main purpose of the proposal is to convince readers or stakeholders that the idea or plan is feasible and useful.
- Proposals usually contain details about the background, problem to be addressed, goals, methods, budget, schedule, and expected benefits of the idea or plan proposed.
- Proposals are used in various contexts, such as business, research, social projects, and more, to gain approval or support to carry out a particular action or project.
With this basic understanding, you can differentiate between a paper and a proposal and identify the purpose and context in which they are used.
Intention and Main Focus of Papers and Proposals
The intention and main focus of a paper and a proposal are different because they are used for different communication purposes. Here are the main intentions and focus of each:
Paper:
-
Main Intention: The main purpose of a paper is to present information, analysis, arguments, or research results about a topic to readers. Papers are used to share knowledge or understanding that the author has gained about the topic.
-
Main Focus: The main focus of the paper is to provide in-depth understanding and analysis details about the topics discussed. This involves constructing a strong argument and supporting it with relevant evidence and references.
-
Audience: Papers are usually addressed to readers who have an interest or knowledge of the topic, such as academic colleagues, researchers, or professionals interested in the same subject.
-
Expected Results: The paper is expected to convey information in a clear and objective manner, allowing the reader to understand the topic better, make an informed decision, or follow the author’s argument.
Proposal:
-
Main Intent: The main purpose of a proposal is to submit an idea, plan, or project to an authorized party or stakeholder with the aim of seeking approval, support, or resources to implement the idea or plan.
-
Main Focus: The main focus of the proposal is to convince readers or stakeholders that the idea or plan is feasible and beneficial. This involves a detailed explanation of the background, problem to be addressed, goals, methods, budget, schedule, and expected benefits of the proposed idea or plan.
-
Audience (Audience): Proposals are usually addressed to parties who have the authority to provide approval or support, such as the organization’s leadership, board of directors, or funding body. The audience usually does not have in-depth knowledge of the topic, so the proposal must explain it well.
-
Expected Results: The proposal is expected to convince readers or stakeholders that the proposed idea or plan is an effective solution to a particular problem or opportunity. The desired outcome is to obtain the approval, support, or resources needed to carry out the plan.
By understanding these differences in intent and primary focus, writers can produce papers and proposals that suit their communication goals and accommodate the needs of different audiences.
Content Format and Organization
The format and content organization in papers and proposals have differences that reflect different goals and audiences. Below, I will explain the general format and structure for both types of documents:
Paper:
-
Pages Title: This is the first page of the paper that includes the title, author’s name, institutional affiliation, and contact information. Also includes an alternative title (if any), keywords, and a brief abstract.
-
Introduction: This section contains the background of the topic, problem statement, objectives , and often a hypothesis (in the context of research). It serves as an introduction detailing why this topic is important.
-
Literature Review: This section documents related research and relevant literature on the topic. This helps context and strengthens the arguments put forward in the paper.
-
Research Methods: If it is a research paper, this section explains the research design, methodology, collection data, and statistical analysis used. It allows the reader to understand how the research was conducted.
-
Results: This is the section where the research findings or data are presented in the form of tables, graphs, or narratives . Usually does not interpret results, only displays them.
-
Discussion: This section discusses and interprets the research results. It allows the author to relate the results to the hypothesis, explain the implications, and provide further analysis.
-
Conclusion: This summarizes the findings and arguments, concluding the paper, and may offer future research directions.
-
Bibliography: List of all references used in the paper according to the specified writing format (such as APA, MLA , or Chicago).
Proposal:
-
Executive Summary: This is a short section that summarizes the proposal as a whole, including background, goals, and expected benefits. This is often the first section a reader reads.
-
Background: This section explains the context or problem the proposal seeks to address. It explains why this proposal is necessary.
-
Problem Statement: Details the problem the proposal seeks to address clearly and in depth.
-
Objectives: Explain what is to be achieved through this proposal and the expected results.
-
Method or Work Plan : This section explains in detail how the proposal will be implemented. It includes the work plan, methods to be used, required resources, schedule, and concrete steps.
-
Budget: If relevant, proposal can include the budget required to carry out the project. This includes estimated costs and expected funding sources.
-
Expected Benefits: Describes the expected benefits and impacts of implementing this proposal.
-
Conclusion: Summarizes the key points of the proposal and makes a strong argument for why this proposal should be approved or supported.
-
Appendix: Attachments contain additional information that supports the proposal, such as graphs, images, references, or other technical information.
When preparing a paper or proposal, it is important to follow an appropriate structure according to the purpose of the document and any guidelines that may be established by the relevant institution or journal. Additionally, make sure to adapt your language and writing style to your intended audience.
Main Content
The main content in papers and proposals differs according to the purpose of each document. Below, I will detail the content typically included in papers and proposals:
Main Content in a Paper:
-
Introduction:
- Topic background: A brief explanation of the context of the topic being discussed.
- Problem statement: An explanation of the problem to be addressed or the research question to be asked answered.
- Aim of the paper: A statement of the main purpose of the paper.
- Hypothesis (if any): A statement about what is hoped to be achieved or proven in the paper.
-
Literature Review:
- List and review of related literature: Introduction to previous studies or works relevant to the topic.
- Identification of knowledge gaps: An explanation of where new research or contributions are needed based on existing literature.
-
Research Methods (if the paper is research):
- Research design: A description of how the research was conducted.
- Data collection: The methods used to collect the data.
- Data analysis: The approach used to analyze data.
- Instruments or tools: Description of the tools or instruments used in the research.
-
Results (if the paper is research):
- Presentation of research findings or data in the form of tables, graphs, or narratives.
- Information related to the question research or hypothesis.
-
Discussion:
- Interpretation of results: Explanation of the meaning of findings or results .
- Relationship to literature: How the research results relate to previous studies.
- Implication: Explanation of the impact or relevance of the results to the broader topic or domain.
-
Conclusion:
- Summarizes the main findings and arguments.
- A conclusion that is fit for purpose paper.
-
Bibliography:
- List of references used in the paper according to the writing format specified (for example, APA, MLA, or Chicago).
Main Content in the Proposal:
-
Executive Summary:
- A brief summary of the proposal as a whole, including background, objectives, and expected benefits.
-
Background:
- The context or problem the proposal seeks to address.
- Explanation why this proposal is needed.
-
Problem Statement:
- In-depth description of the problem to be addressed by the proposal.
-
Goals:
- Long-term goals and specific goals to be achieved through a proposal.
-
Method or Work Plan:
- Details of how the proposal will be implemented, including the steps to be taken.
- Resource arrangements and implementation schedule.
-
Budget (if relevant):
- Estimated costs required to implement the project.
- Expected sources of funding.
-
Expected Benefits:
- Explanation of the expected benefits and impacts of implementing the proposal.
-
Conclusion:
- Summarizes the main points of the proposal and presents a strong argument for why this proposal should be approved or supported.
-
Attachments:
- Additional information that supports the proposal, such as graphs, images, references, or other technical information.
This content helps explain the purpose, relevance, and implementation plans in both the paper and proposal. Be sure to adapt the content to the purpose and intended audience to achieve the desired results.
Writing Directions
Writing directions in papers and proposals are essential to ensure the quality and conformity of the document to academic standards or professional. Some style guidelines and references that are often used in writing papers and proposals are:
1. Writing Format:
- Margins and Space: Typically, use 1 inch (2.54 cm) margins on all sides and double space (unless otherwise specified ).
- Font: Use an easy-to-read font, such as Times New Roman or Arial, in 12-point size.
- Page Numbers: Page numbers are usually placed in the top right corner or bottom center of the page.
- Header or Title: Format the title or header according to the style guidelines used (for example, APA, MLA , or Chicago).
2. Writing Style:
- Word Choice: Use words that are appropriate and appropriate for the topic. Avoid jargon that is not commonly understood by the general audience.
- Uniformity: Ensure uniformity in writing, including the use of tense (past, present, future), grammar, and general writing style .
3. Quotations and References:
- Citations: When you use someone else’s information, ideas, or words, provide proper citation and provide the source.
- Reference List: Create a precise and complete list of references according to the style guidelines used (APA, MLA, Chicago, etc.).
4. Style Guidelines:
- APA (American Psychological Association): Commonly used in the social sciences and behavioral sciences.
- MLA (Modern Language Association): Commonly used in the humanities and literature.
- Chicago (Manual of Style): Used in various disciplines, especially history and social sciences .
5. Tables and Figures:
- Use tables and figures when necessary to visualize data or information.
- Provide clear labels and captions for tables and figures, and include them the source.
6. Specific Language and Style:
- In business proposals, use language that emphasizes economic and strategic benefits.
- In research proposals, use language that emphasizes scientific significance or social aspects of the project.
7. Proofreading and Revision:
- Check your paper or proposal carefully for grammar, spelling, and punctuation errors.
- Revise your document to ensure that the argument and ideas are organized logically and effectively.
8. Plagiarism:
- Avoid plagiarism by properly citing sources and honestly acknowledging other people’s contributions to your work.
9. Institution or Journal Guidelines:
- Follow any writing guidelines that may be provided by the academic institution or journal to which you will submit your paper or proposal.
It is important to always refer to style guidelines appropriate to the discipline or context in which you are writing your paper or proposal. This will help ensure that your document meets the standards expected by your readers and stakeholders.
Target Audience
The target audience or audiences addressed by papers and proposals differ based on their respective objectives. each document. Here is an overview of the audiences typically targeted in papers and proposals:
Papers:
-
Academic Colleagues: In an academic context, a paper is often addressed to colleagues or researchers in the same or related disciplines. This audience has deep knowledge and interest in the topic discussed in the paper.
-
Instructor or Lecturer: In academic settings, papers written by students are often This is often addressed to instructors or lecturers who give assignments or supervise research. These instructors usually have a good understanding of the topic.
-
Other Academic Readers: Research papers published in scientific journals or presented at conferences can be addressed to wider audience in certain disciplines. They are researchers or academic professionals who have an interest in the topic.
-
General Reader: In some cases, papers may be written for a wider audience or general readership, especially if the paper is intended for popular publication or communicating scientific information to the general public.
Proposal:
-
Stakeholders or Authorities: Proposals are often addressed to authorities or stakeholders who have the power to provide approval, support, or resources for the proposed project or initiative. This could be a senior manager, board of directors or funding body.
-
Client or Customer: In the context of a business or service project, the proposal may be addressed to the client or potential customers. This proposal tries to convince the client or customer that the proposed solution or service is the best for them.
-
External Interested Parties: Social, non-profit project proposals , or government is often addressed to external interested parties, such as donor agencies, community organizations, or local governments.
-
Project Team or Colleagues: In some cases, proposals may be addressed to project team members or internal colleagues for internal approval or support.
-
Wider Audience (in Community Project Proposals): Community project proposals may be aimed at local residents or the wider community who will benefit from the project.
It is important to understand the target audience well when drafting paper or proposal. Writers must adapt their writing style, language, and communication approach to suit the knowledge and interests of their intended audience. With a good understanding of who is the target, papers and proposals will be more effective in achieving their goals.
Preparation Time
The time for preparing papers and proposals is different because they both have different stages and processes according to the purpose and complexity of each document. The following are the differences in the process of creating these two types of documents:
Paper Preparation Process:
-
Research and Planning
: The process of preparing a paper begins with research on the topic to be discussed. It involves collecting reference materials, reviewing the literature, and forming a deep understanding of the subject. In addition, the author plans the structure and scope of the paper. -
Data Collection (If Relevant): If the paper is the result of research, the author will collect data that required according to the planned research method.
-
Draft Writing: After planning the paper and collecting data (if necessary), the writer starts writing the first draft. This includes writing the main sections such as introduction, literature review, methods, results, and discussion.
-
Revise and Improve: After completing the first draft, the author makes revisions to improve structure, grammar, and content. This process may be repeated several times to ensure optimal quality of the paper.
-
Reference Organization: The author creates a list of references according to appropriate style guidelines (such as APA , MLA, or Chicago).
-
Abstract Preparation: An abstract or executive summary in accordance with certain guidelines is prepared to provide a brief overview of the paper.
-
Finalization: The final paper is checked for errors in spelling, punctuation, and final details before being submitted for publication or presentation.
Proposal Preparation Process:
-
Problem or Opportunity Identification: The proposal preparation process begins with identifying the problem or opportunities that the proposal will address. It involves analysis of the situation and a deep understanding of the context.
-
Planning and Research: The writer plans the proposal by detailing the objectives, methods, work plan, and budget required. It also involves research to support the arguments in the proposal.
-
Writing a Draft Proposal: After planning the proposal, the writer starts writing the draft proposal. It includes all sections such as background, problem statement, objectives, methods, budget, expected benefits, etc.
-
Consultation with Related Parties: In many cases, proposal writers interact with related parties or stakeholders to obtain input or support before the proposal is fully drafted.
-
Revisions and Improvements: After completing the first draft, the writer makes revisions to improve the structure, grammar and content of the proposal. This process may involve several iterations.
-
Proposal Finalization: The final proposal is reviewed and refined, including the addition of attachments or supporting documents if necessary.
-
Proposal Submission: The proposal is ready to be submitted to the authorities or intended stakeholders.
Differences The main thing in the preparation process is that papers focus more on investigation, analysis, and communication of information or findings, while proposals focus more on planning and convincing authorities or stakeholders to support a project or initiative. Because of this, proposals tend to have stages that are more oriented towards strategic planning and communication.
Response and Feedback
Response and responses to documents such as papers and proposals can vary depending on the audience, the quality of the document , as well as its purpose and context. The following are several things that may happen when this document is received and processed by authorized parties or readers:
Response to the Paper:
-
Peer Review: If a paper is submitted for publication in a scientific journal, it will usually undergo a peer review process. Peers will evaluate the paper for quality, methodology, and contribution to knowledge.
-
Assessment by Instructor or Examiner: If the paper is submitted in an academic context, the instructor or the examiner will assess the paper based on predetermined criteria. This may affect the assessment and final grade.
-
Response from General Readers: If the paper is widely published or available to the general reader, responses may vary. Some readers may evaluate the paper critically, while others may only read it for information.
-
Feedback from Peers or Mentors: Authors of papers may receive feedback from colleagues or mentors who help to improve the quality of the paper.
-
Publication: If the paper is published, it can gain attention in the academic or professional community, and may receive responses or quotations from other authors.
Response to Proposal:
-
Evaluation by Authorities: Proposals will be assessed by the authorities responsible for providing approval, support, or resources. They will assess the proposals based on predetermined criteria.
-
Consultations with Relevant Parties: Authorities or stakeholders may carry out consultations with related parties or other experts before making a decision.
-
Negotiation: In some cases, there is room for negotiation between the proposal writer and the competent authority. This may mean revising or adjusting the proposal before final approval.
-
Decision: The proposal will be accepted, rejected, or given approval under certain conditions. This decision will influence whether the project or initiative is implemented.
-
Project Implementation: If the proposal is approved, the project or initiative implementation process will begin according to the plan described in the proposal.
-
Monitoring and Evaluation: Once the project is underway, there may be monitoring and evaluation to ensure that the project is proceeding as planned and delivering the expected results .
-
Post-Implementation Feedback: After the project is completed, there is the possibility of post-implementation feedback from authorities or stakeholders that can be used for improvements in future.
It is important to remember that responses and reactions to this document may vary widely, and the quality of the document and the author’s ability to explain and persuade the audience will influence the outcome. In many cases, effective communication and the use of strong data or evidence are key to the acceptance of a paper or proposal.
Use in Different Contexts
Papers and proposals are used in a variety of different contexts, each with a special purpose. Here are some contexts in which papers and proposals are used:
Papers:
-
Academic Context:
- Academic Research: Papers are used to communicate the results of scientific research to the academic community. This may include research papers, theses, dissertations, or research project reports.
- Coursework: Students are often asked to write papers as part of their coursework to demonstrate their understanding of the material being taught.
-
Scientific Journals: Papers are often published in scientific journals to share research findings with the wider scientific community.
-
Scientific Conferences: Papers can be presented at scientific conferences as a means of sharing research and discussing with colleagues.
-
Research Reports: Organizations, research institutions, or governments often request papers as research reports on a particular topic.
Proposals:
-
Business Context:
- Business Proposal: Used to propose a business plan or project to shareholders, investors, or financial parties to obtain funding or support.
- Bid Proposal: Used in the tender process to compete for contracts or projects with other companies or institutions.
-
Non-Profit and Social Contexts:
- Non-Profit Project Proposals: Used by non-profit organizations to obtain funds from donors or funding bodies for charitable projects or social.
- Social Research Proposal: Used in social research and science
